|
| PERSPECTIVE |
Reported by Donna
Wilson, STATEWIDE Correspondent

[Michaela] "In the wintertime, it's hard. There's
ice and stuff. Last year my friend, she slipped."
It's a cold December
morning and Michaela is one of the first children on the bus. It will take
Michaela and her schoolmates 45 minutes in a dozen miles of rush hour interstate
traffic to get to school.
[Students on bus]"Well,
it's fast....And it's bumpy."
Finally at school, the
bus riders' day began more than an hour ago.
[Concerned Parent]"What
about us?"
Parents and community
leaders are talking about whether Omaha school kids should be on the bus at
all?
[Concerned Parent]"Riding
the bus is not the answer to any of this."
The O.P.S. Desegregation
Study Task Force has met every other week since the fall of 1997.
[Concerned Parent]"And
I say this because I'm really being -- getting concerned here that we're starting
to talk about a bunch of junk, that's the best way I can say it. I don't care
anything about how long you ride the bus. That is of no concern to me. What
I'm really concerned about is the quality of education that my child gets
when he or she gets to school and back home."
It costs $15 million annually to bus Omaha public school students. 20 years
after court-imposed desegregation busing began, students are no longer bused
solely to integrate schools.
[Dr. John Mackiel, O.P.S.
Superintendent] "We have transportation available for special education
students, English as a Second Language students, magnet school students, and
the transportation price tag for the deseg
regation purposes is approximately $5.5 to 6 million
of that 15."
Less explosive than
some areas of the country, Omaha's implementation of forced busing was strained
but went off with few hitches.
[old film footage-narrator]
"During this time while the busing program was just getting underway,
the Omaha school board decided to appeal the circuit court's busing order.
But the decision to fight forced busing was by no means a unanimous mouse
one."
But the impetus for busing
was heated. It manifested in a court battle. In 1973 African-American parents
filed a lawsuit against Omaha Public Schools. Their claim? Institutional racism.
That O.P.S. schools were illegally segregated. Dave Pedersen is an attorney
for O.P.S. He has been involved with the busing case for 23 years.
[Dave Pedersen] "You
see the premise for the courts ordering schools to mandatorily reassign kids
was that you intentionally violated someone's constitutional rights, and the
school district felt that it had not intentionally violated anyone's constitutional
rights and that essentially the racial separation that we had in the schools
was because of people's residential housing choices and that all we were doing
was running essentially a neighborhood school."
In the late 1960's and
early 1970's, discriminatory housing practices and high concentrations of
African-Americans in the inner city made predominantly black schools more
common. Black parents said their schools were being neglected. When busing
first began, white children were bused two years while black children were
bused five.
From the beginning, parents questioned the fairness
of the plan. At the time black children were only 20% of the O.P.S. population.
The court looked at the numbers saying more busing for black students was
the only resolution. Today white kids are bused either in 2nd or 3rd grade
while black kids are bused in 4th through 6th. And like white kids possibly
7th and 8th if there's no school in their neighborhood.
It's another typical
cold Nebraska day when most parents would rather not send their kids to stand
outside and wait for a bus.
[Robert Bauldwin]"Many
children become isolated."
Robert Bauldwin is one such parent. Bauldwin attended Omaha Public Schools
later to drop out partly he says because even with integrated schools, racism
ran rampant. Now he has five children who attend O.P.S. He believes desegregation
busing is inherently racist, that busing black children out of their neighborhoods
sends a clearly negative message.
[Robert Bauldwin] "Busing
is billion dollar industry. Trick black people into making them think you
can get a better education by your child sitting next to a white child and
what this does is make the black child still feel inferior. He has to leave
his community to go somewhere else to feel he can get an education."
One of Bauldwin's children
is Roberta. She is a student at King Science Center. This year she rides the
bus. It's only a 15-minute ride but she's ridden longer. Her father is very
involved with her education.
[Roberta] "The reason
I get good grades is because I love myself and I'm able to love other people
and that gives me the strength and it's all because I love myself."
But when Roberta was
bused further away, it was more difficult for Bauldwin to interact with teachers,
and Roberta found it more difficult to interact with kids who lived near her
but didn't go to the same school.
[Bauldwin] "What
integration did, it deteriorated the very fibers of our community. I never
get to know the child across the street because for six and a half hours of
the day he is out of the community. The school system must integrate the curriculum.
If the new superintendent really wants to be nice to black people and he truly
likes black people and he truly wants to do the right thing for black people,
integrate the curriculum."
In the mid-1980's, magnet schools like King Science Center opened and the
courts said the desegregation plan had "worked well." Tell that
to the parents who are part of the deseg task force. The segregation may have
been eliminated but other issues would pop up. A young teacher then, John
McKeel, remembers when busing began. He recalls the bumper stickers which
read "let's make it work."
[John MCKeel]"Very
candidly the issue is we're growing weary of placing our babies on the corners
when the windchill is 30 below and wondering if, in fact, a bus will be there
within a 10-minute window, within a 30-minute window, will, in fact, that
bus show up at all."
[Wilson]"You're
the person that gets the complaint from the parent."
[Bus Driver]"I get
a lot of them."
[Wilson]"What sort
do you get?"
[Bus Driver]"Well,
obviously the normal, the bus is late, the bus missed my child, they did not
drop the child off at the right stop."
Those are just the logistics.
With changing demographics, the greater issue is whether desegregation busing
is still relevant.
[Dawn Buchanan] "There
are more Hispanics and Asian-Americans. I just think we need to look at all
of the different cultures we have in Omaha."
Members of the busing
task force have three choices -- end it, change it, or leave it alone. Most
don't want to leave it alone. Dawn Buchanan lives in west Omaha. She has two
kids who have been bused. She says it was a good experience for them.
[Buchanan] "The
fact that kids are bused three more years than my kids had been bused out
west, I had concerns about that, too, but, you know, once they explained that,
you know, 20 years ago the numbers of African-Americans and Whites, since
it is that kind of issue, was so much different, it made sense to me that
you would have to bus that way."
Tony Rabiola has three
school age children. He says he spent half a year taking the kids to school
himself. He was in high school when deseg busing first began.
[Tony Rabiola] "I
didn't think it was that awful of an experience but I was older when I went
through it, too. I wasn't in the 2nd grade like my kids were and had to be
bused for the entire year. So for the younger kids, I just don't think it's
a great way to run things. Currently, there is a voluntary system in place
for the high schools. And I don't see why something similar to that couldn't
be worked out for the middle schools and elementary where every child would
have either their neighborhood school or a choice of schools, magnet schools
to go to. "
Ivan Gilreath has one
son who has been bused and a daughter who will be for the first time next
year. He lives in an integrated neighborhood and says forced busing may be
forcing out students.
[Ivan Gilreath] "I
think they've gone to Millard, I think they've gone to private schools. I
think it's because they just don't want to have their kids bused. I think
that's something that needs to be addressed as well, because I think we're
losing, you know, some quality individuals from our school district because
of the existing busing plan."
[Presenter]"That
is the challenge because there is still a concentration. They are not mixed
all over town. And that has been the dilemma."
If there are people moving
from school to school or from neighborhood to neighborhood, the majority are
not black students. Most black students remain concentrated in particular
areas of Omaha. O.P.S. has 30% black students, 10% Hispanic, and about 2%
Asian. With all of the new diversity, why concentrate on black students? Well,
because the initial plan was based on a lawsuit by black parents. At the time
far fewer ethnicities attended O.P.S. But other litigation is pending by parents
who believe diversity is no excuse.
[Pedersen] "Most
of the lawsuits, though, currently are being brought by people that are claiming
school districts that are unitary school districts like Omaha is who still
use race as a criterion for student assignment although for remedial purposes
are violating their constitutional rights since the only basis -- this is
what these people are claiming -- the only basis on which you can use race
for student assignments is to remedy your past discriminatory action. You
can't use it for such purposes as promoting diversity in student assignments."
[Presenter]"If you
would have four glasses and three glasses had blue marbles in them and one
glass had green marbles and your chore was to move and mix those blue and
green marbles equitably so that each glass had the same amount of blue and
green marbles, you would find you would be moving the green marbles three
times more frequently than the blue. I think just mathematically that happens."
Some parents believe
the current busing plan is right on target. Others believe O.P.S. lost its
marbles a long time ago.
[Parent ]"Are those
guidelines written down, ma'am?"
Several public hearings have come and gone. There has been low turnout, but
one mantra which has come up time and again, parents are demanding choice
and involvement in their children's education. Who cares about systems and
buses, they say. They want good educations for their kids. It's a debate which
started a long time ago.
[Bauldwin] "My main
thing is to end it, end busing. Our black children are bused four times more
than white children. Out of a four-year period, our children spend one year
on the bus. Now all these white people like black people so much and want
us to be a part of an A-1 system, why don't they think everything equal then?"
Task force members know
there is a long road ahead.
Captioning
by Nebraska Captioning Center, Lincoln, Nebraska.