Media Circus: Who Won? The Moderator

Atmospherically, the vice presidential debate pitted old versus new. Vice President Joe Biden lives in a world where no lily goes ungilded, and every lative is super. Rep. Paul Ryan speeds through campaigning energetically, like the heroic train in the new movie "Atlas Got Cut Using the P90X Workout."

And the moderator Martha Raddatz? She came out guns blazing. No avuncular, passive Jim Lehrer she.

Indeed, Raddatz started the evening with a touch of Catskills, telling people in the audience "I've spent a good deal of time in war zones, so I'm not used to sitting with my back to the audience."

She was not intimidated by the two politicians, no matter how polished they were, or how willing they were to use the word "malarkey." (On that score: Biden 3, Ryan 0.)

First question to Biden on the assault on the American consulate where the U.S. ambassador to Libya and three other Americans were murdered: "Wasn't this a massive intelligence failure, Vice President Biden?"

Later to Ryan, on former Gov. Romney's detail-free promise to reduce taxes and eliminate enough deductions to compensate for the lost five trillion in federal revenues: "You have refused yet again to offer specifics on how you pay for that 20 percent across-the-board tax cut. Do you actually have the specifics, or are you still working on it, and that's why you won't tell voters?"

Ryan ultimately says: "It is mathematically possible." But still no specifics.

Ryan had signaled before the debate he wasn't to be addressed as "Congressman Ryan" but "Mr. Ryan" – an apparent effort to distance himself from the unpopularity from which Congress uniformly suffers. Seventeen minutes in, Raddatz was referring to him as "Representative Ryan."

Biden interrupted far more than was polite, but Raddatz kept the debate moving with a light but firm touch – allowing the often barbed back and forth Lehrer said he was seeking to foster between Obama and Romney. Biden and Ryan talked about the same amount of time during the 90 minutes of the event, according to CNN's tabulation.

Romney was himself not punished for his own aggressive posture in interrupting Obama and Lehrer last week; undoubtedly the Obama camp took note. Biden showed restraint just once: when Ryan invoked "Jack Kennedy" as a Democrat willing to work across the aisle, Biden riposted, "Oh, now you're Jack Kennedy!" Somehow he managed not to repeat Lloyd Bentsen's unforgettable line about JFK verbatim. It was impossible not to think he wanted to.

Raddatz, an ABC correspondent, not a network anchor, was the one uncontested winner of the night, serious and even-handed.

Biden showed fire and served as (a liberal) fact-checker in real time; Ryan presented an earnestness and seriousness of purpose. And the debate that ensued was substantive. Attacks from a conservative news site, The Daily Caller, that she was compromised by the role her ex-husband plays within the Obama administration, seemed all the more flimsy after the debate played out. (She divorced Julius Genachowski, the current chairman of the Federal Communications Commission and a Harvard Law classmate of the president, in 1997, the same year Obama became a state senator in Illinois.)

Perhaps predictably, Fox News talk show host Sean Hannity called her "the worst moderator." Lehrer's inability to push back on falsehoods or distortions in real time was widely mocked.

Critics of Jim Lehrer last week were numerous, but more so on the political left, given Obama's failure to punch back at Romney.

On Thursday night, Raddatz challenged the two candidates on their specifics, though on the whole she didn't fact check either. Instead, she called their bluff on responses that sidestepped and deflected.

One of her final queries, about the meanness of political campaigns, came off as naïve, something she decidedly is not – and could have been asked of candidates dating back to John Adams and Thomas Jefferson. All in all, however, Raddatz redeemed the idea of an establishment journalist leading the debate.

Copyright 2012 National Public Radio. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.